PT 3: Why Hiring Managers and Recruiters Clash (And How to Fix It)

Welcome to the final instalment of our series on the recruiter-hiring manager relationship. If you've been following along, we've explored everything from knowledge gaps to overselling candidates.

Now, we'll break down the last three crucial deal-breakers that can undermine the hiring process:

• Inflexibility

• Poor communication

• Lack of transparency.

7. The 'One-Size-Fits-All' Fallacy: A Rigid Process

Every role is unique, and every hiring manager has specific needs. When a recruiter applies a rigid, cookie-cutter process to every search, it signals they aren't listening. This inflexibility is a major source of frustration, as it ignores the very nuances that define a great hire.

A one-size-fits-all approach leads to predictable failures:

• Mismatched strategies: Using the same sourcing methods for a common role as for a highly specialized one, leading to poor results.

• Hiring manager disengagement: Managers feel their expertise is ignored when a recruiter refuses to adapt the process to their feedback.

• Poor candidate experience: Forcing top talent through irrelevant screening steps or interview formats that don't fit the role.

The fix: The best recruiters act as strategic consultants, not just process managers. They demonstrate flexibility by tailoring their sourcing, screening, and communication style to fit the specific needs of the role and the preferences of the hiring manager.

8. The Communication Black Hole: No News is Bad News

In recruitment, silence is never golden. Poor communication, characterized by long periods of silence or vague, unhelpful updates, can bring the hiring process to a grinding halt. It creates uncertainty and leaves both hiring managers and candidates feeling completely in the dark.

When communication breaks down, the consequences are immediate:

• Project delays: Hiring managers can't plan effectively without knowing the status of their candidate pipeline.

• Lost candidates: Top talent will quickly lose interest and accept other offers if they don't receive timely feedback or updates.

• Erosion of trust: A lack of consistent communication makes the recruiter seem disorganized and uninvested in the search.

The fix: Effective communication is proactive, consistent, and clear. Establishing a regular communication schedule, whether it's a daily check-in or a weekly summary report, ensures everyone is aligned, manages expectations, and keeps the process moving forward smoothly.

9. Hidden Truths: When Transparency Takes a Backseat

Transparency is the foundation of trust in the recruiter-hiring manager relationship. When recruiters withhold crucial information such as a candidate's salary expectations, potential concerns from a reference check, or a lack of specific skills they create a partnership built on incomplete truths.

This lack of transparency makes it impossible for hiring managers to make informed decisions and often leads to:

• Late-stage surprises: Offers are rejected over salary misalignments that should have been addressed upfront.

• Poor hiring decisions: Managers move forward with candidates based on an incomplete or misleading picture.

• A complete breakdown of the partnership: Once a hiring manager realizes information was deliberately withheld, the recruiter's credibility is permanently damaged.

The fix: A true talent partner shares the full picture including the strengths, the weaknesses, and the realities of the market. Being upfront about challenges builds a collaborative relationship where problems can be solved together, ultimately leading to better, more sustainable hires.

• Read Part 1

• Read Part 2

Let us know your thoughts, we'd love to hear from you!